How to Manage Volunteers Who Work With Children

If your program puts volunteers in contact with children or teenagers, the stakes are different. Not because your volunteers aren't trustworthy, but because trust is exactly the thing you need to protect. A robust screening and supervision process isn't a sign of distrust. It's what makes your program something families can actually rely on.

This applies whether you're running an after-school tutoring program, a youth sports league, a mentorship program, or an annual event where children are participants. Any context where volunteers work alongside minors requires intentional policies, not just good intentions.

Start With Screening Before Anything Else

The first and most foundational step is running background checks on every volunteer who will interact with children. No exceptions, no "but they've been with us for years" carve-outs. Background check policies should apply uniformly, and that consistency is part of what makes them credible to parents and funders.

What kind of check you need depends on your state, your program type, and sometimes your funders' requirements. At a minimum, most child-serving nonprofits run a national criminal background check and a sex offender registry check. Some programs also run reference checks that specifically ask about work with children.

Build screening into your volunteer application from the start: "All volunteers working with minors are required to complete a background check as part of our program requirements." Frame it as a standard part of onboarding, not as an accusation.

Some volunteers will push back, especially long-timers who feel their track record should speak for itself. You can acknowledge that while holding the line: "I know you've been with us for a long time and I trust you completely. This policy applies to everyone, and having it apply uniformly is what gives it teeth."

Set Clear Supervision Ratios

How many adults need to be present per child varies by program type, age group, and sometimes legal requirement. Check your state's regulations for your specific type of program.

Beyond legal minimums, apply common sense. A situation where a single volunteer is alone with a child should trigger your two-adult rule or open-door rule: never have a child and a single adult in a private, unobservable space. This protects children, and it also protects your volunteers from false accusations.

For larger events, think through supervision ratios before the day. If you're expecting 40 children at a Saturday program, how many volunteers do you need to maintain appropriate ratios throughout? Factor in breaks, setup, and the reality that not every volunteer will be in the same place at the same time.

There's more on planning volunteer coverage for larger programs in the guide to running a volunteer orientation for large groups, including how to brief volunteers on their roles and responsibilities before they interact with participants.

Write Your Child Safeguarding Policy Down

A lot of small nonprofits operate with unspoken norms rather than written policies, which works until it doesn't. If you have volunteers working with children, you need a written child safeguarding policy that every volunteer reads and signs.

Your policy doesn't need to be a 20-page document. At a minimum, it should cover:

• Who is required to have a background check
• Supervision ratios and the two-adult rule
• How to report a concern, suspicion, or incident (and the mandatory reporting requirements in your state)
• Communication policies (more on this below)
• Prohibited conduct, including physical discipline, sharing personal contact information with participants, and social media contact with minors in the program

Clear volunteer policies are the foundation of a program that operates with integrity. Having them in writing also protects your organization if something goes wrong, because you can show that expectations were clearly communicated and consistently enforced.

Handle Communications Carefully

One of the trickier areas is how volunteers communicate with the youth in your program. Well-meaning volunteers sometimes start texting or messaging participants directly, which creates situations that are hard to monitor and can become problematic.

The general rule: all communication between volunteers and youth participants should go through the organization, not through personal channels. Volunteers shouldn't give out their personal phone numbers, and program-related communication with minors should go through a parent, guardian, or program coordinator.

If you run a mentorship or tutoring program where ongoing communication is part of the model, set up a channel you can monitor: a program email account, a messaging app that logs conversations, or simply requiring that parents are always copied.

When you go through volunteer orientation, make sure communication policies are covered explicitly. Don't assume volunteers will know the norms. Say it out loud and put it in writing.

Prepare Volunteers for Difficult Moments

Children don't always arrive at volunteer programs in easy circumstances. A youth who seems disruptive may be dealing with something serious at home. A participant who discloses something troubling puts your volunteer in a position they may never have navigated before.

Volunteers working with youth need to know, in advance, three things:

They are not counselors. Their job is not to fix problems or solve crises. Their job is to be present, supportive, and to report concerns to program staff.

How to report a concern. Who to tell, what to say, how quickly. This should be in your policy, and it should also be covered verbally during training.

Mandatory reporting requirements. In most states, anyone working with children in an organized program may be classified as a mandatory reporter. Know your state's rules and communicate them clearly to your volunteers before they start.

Preparing volunteers for difficult situations in general is a good starting point. Programs working with youth should go deeper on child-specific scenarios during orientation, including what to do if a child makes a disclosure.

Renew and Refresh Annually

Safeguarding isn't a one-time setup. Background checks expire (most programs re-run them annually or every two years). Volunteers come and go. Policies need updating as your program evolves and as legal requirements change.

Schedule an annual policy review. It doesn't need to be long. Thirty minutes spent re-reading your safeguarding policy and asking "does this still reflect how we operate?" is worth doing every year. If your program has grown, or your participant population has changed, you may find gaps you didn't have before.

The small nonprofits that run the strongest youth programs aren't the ones with the most elaborate systems. They're the ones that take safeguarding seriously from the start, document it, and revisit it regularly. Families trust you with the people they love most. That trust is worth protecting.

Where Volunteer Shift Manager Fits

Volunteer Shift Manager doesn't handle background checks or safeguarding policies, and you'll need a dedicated provider for those. What it does do is give you a clear, real-time view of who's signed up for each shift, which helps when you're tracking ratios or need to know quickly who your confirmed volunteers are for a given session.

For programs that require specific certifications or training before a volunteer can be rostered, keeping that information in your volunteer records outside the scheduling tool is the right approach. Your shift tool is one piece of a larger system, and knowing who's cleared to work with children is part of the coordinator's responsibility, not something software can fully automate.

---

Volunteer Shift Manager is built for small nonprofits coordinating volunteers across programs and shifts.